609-845-3576

Metal Roofs Vs. Shingles: Which Is Best For Your Home?

Posted on December 22, 2022

Estimated Reading Time : 7 Min.

Share Now :

Metal Roofs Vs. Shingles: Which Is Best For Your Home?

Today, you can choose from many different kinds of roofs. Some of them, like shingles, have been around for a long time, while others, such as metal, have just recently been developed. While both of these roofs are great options for your home, you must know the pros and cons of each so you can make an informed choice about which type of roof would be best for your home.

Understanding Metal Roofs

A roof constructed of metals such as steel, aluminum, and copper is known as a metal roof. Although there are many roofing types available that people conventionally choose from, metal roofing has taken over the market with its durability and longevity. Now, metal roofing system is one of the preferable options for homeowners in the United States and worldwide.

You may not have noticed the metal roofing systems around you, but they are everywhere. As the myths about metal roofing are progressively busted by industry experts, homeowners are shifting to metal roofs.

Moreover, metal roofs are long sheets of metal that overlap each other and form a durable, thick, layer. They come in various shapes, designs, and colors, which give an outstanding makeover to your roof. Metal roofs are a one-time expense due to their thickness, durability, and longevity, but they are still the most profitable choice compared to other roofing materials, which are inexpensive but require timely repairs and maintenance.

metal roof

Understanding Shingle Roofs

Shingle roofs, unlike metal roofs, are made of asphalt, wood, and fiberglass. Asphalt shingles are ideally plastic and can be molded in any desired shape and size. That is why they come in pieces, sheets, and stacks.

However, asphalt shingles need no introduction. Homeowners in the U.S. are aware of what asphalt shingles are, and if people have not installed metal roofs on their homes, they have most likely installed asphalt shingles.

Shingle roofs are more economical and easier to install than metal sheets. In addition, they come with a warranty covering damage to their seal, and water leaks. To keep your shingle roofs protecting you and your family for a long time, experts recommend maintaining your roof in a timely manner. In the case that you fail at their upkeep, shingles may deteriorate before their lifespan of 25-30 years.

Metal Vs Shingle 2

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Metal Roofs

Advantages Of Metal Roofing

There are many benefits for people who opt for metal roofing. Though metal sheets are the preferred roofing material, they are only suitable for some homeowners. Whether metal roofing will suit your home depends on your budget and location. Let’s have a look at metal roofing’s benefits and advantages.

#1 Durable 

Durability is the measure of what the material can withstand without deteriorating, specifically, how it can withstand the elements. In regions where baseball-sized hail commonly falls on roofs, shingles are known to easily deteriorate. This damage in the conventional shingles further damages the roof and can cause the water to leak through.

In contrast to asphalt and wood shingles, metal roofs are more durable and rigid to oppose the impact produced by objects like hail. In addition, metal roofs reflect UV rays and restrict their absorption of them. The high durability of metal roofs extends their longevity.

#2 Long Lasting 

Because metal roofs are less likely to be damaged by hail hits and harmful UV rays, they are known to last longer than shingles. Moreover, metal roofs can accompany your home for over 50 years, which is longer than some other materials on the market. In addition, metal roofs satisfy people’s longing to install a once-in-a-lifetime roof.

Also, metal roofs prevent algae and plant growth, which is a plus for many homeowners.

#3 Non-flammable

Class A fire rating is a rating that measures the flammable nature of materials. Because metal roofs fall into the Class A fire rating category, this means they are unlikely to catch fire or contribute to it. Metal roofs are one of the best protective roofing materials to cover your home with if you live in wildfire-prone areas.

#4 Water Resistant

There is no doubt that metal roofs are water resistant. This quality of metal roofs allows them to last longer than other materials, like shingles. Metal roofs are installed in a way that they are slanted to direct the rain and other precipitation to slide off the roofs.

However, metal roofs require timely maintenance. You will need to check and maintain your roof in case there is a compilation of debris such as leaves, and branches, which can stop the water flow.

Though the water-resistant property of metal roofs makes them durable and sturdy, they can still be affected by water. Specifically, ponded water that has been blocked on your roof from debris and sitting for a long time, can cause corrosion and rot.

#5 Low Maintenance And Eco Friendly

The slanted construction of metal roofs allows the compilation of leaves and debris to slide off with the flow of rainwater, and you will need little maintenance effort to keep water flowing freely off your roof.

Though metal roofs require low maintenance you should still keep a close eye on your roof, and ensure that no debris is blocking water. With the ability to be recycled after their long life is over, metal roofs are a good choice for homeowners looking to choose a roofing material that is eco-friendly.

Disadvantages Of Metal Roofing

Although metal roofs are packed with benefits and advantages, they come with some downfalls as well. Below we have presented a couple of disadvantages of metal roofing that are isolated from the myths and fears people assume about them.

#1 Expensive Roofing 

Metal roofing is expensive yet profitable if you are looking for a once-in-a-lifetime roofing installation. It may not be priced the same roof shingles but metal roofs are worth their price in the long run. The total installation cost will involve labor, materials, and the installation process.

#2 Challenging Installation

One of the disadvantages of metal roofing is its installation. Not only because you want to be careful not to dent the metal during installation, but also because there is a short supply of skilled and qualified metal roofers. With the installation being trickier, and the metals being expensive, you’ll want to call a skilled professional for assistance if you’re considering a metal roof for your home.

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Asphalt Shingles

Advantages of Shingle Roofing

Shingle roofs are the best option if you want an economical, yet sustainable, roof for your home. They come with a list of advantages which we’ve provided below to help you make better and more informed decisions.

So, let’s dive into the advantages of asphalt shingles.

#1 Economical 

Shingle roofs, as mentioned above, are economical and profitable to many homeowners. The economic classification of shingles increases their availability everywhere in the world. Also, asphalt shingles being economically cheaper than metal sheets, satisfy the needs of most homeowners.

#2 Easy To Install

The cost and process itself make the installation of shingles cost-effective. Shingle roofing requires less time and labor, making the process easy for the contractor, and the homeowner. Because they come as ready-to-install bundles, they are easy to install.

The roofer can directly install the shingles on the roof deck with the help of screws.

#3 Affordable To Repair 

Though many factors affect the age of shingles roofs, water is one of the major concerns. Having pooled water on an asphalt shingle roof deteriorates the shingles, sometimes causing them to curl up, allowing water to leak under them. Luckily, asphalt shingles are affordable to repair.

#4 No Limit To Skilled Contractors 

Since shingles are easy to install and replace, there is no limit to the number of skilled and professional shingle contractors out there. Shingles are economical and affordable, which makes room in a homeowner’s budget to hire a professional contractor to install them.

Disadvantages Of Shingles Roofing

#1 Less Energy Efficient

Though Asphalt shingles are the popular choice among the homeowners and roofers, they are less energy efficient then the metal roofing. Metal roofs because of their higher reflectivity, reflect the greater amount of incident heat. However, asphalt shingles can absorb the heat and warm up the home interior, making you spend more to cool your home interior.

But there are other ways which can cut short your air conditioning bills. You can do reflective coating on your roof shingles to transform them into a good heat reflector.

What Is More Expensive? Metal Roofing Vs. Shingles

What is more expensive is a question that needs you to dive in to check several factors. For that, let us help you to find out the cost of the two in this section.

Asphalt Shingles Cost More In The Long Run. 

Asphalt shingles are conventionally more economical than the other roofing types. Their cost typically ranges between $5,700 and $12,000 which includes material and installation. Or, it can vary depending on your location and the temperature in your area. At the same time, their labor costs for installation are less expensive. Additionally, roof shingles are readied to accompany you for 25 – 30 years.

Though asphalt shingles are economically valued, they require repair and replacement services more often. So, in the long term, asphalt shingles can be more expensive.

Metal Roofs Cost Less In The Short Term

In contrast to shingle roofs, metal roofs are expensive for a one-time cost. Their one-time installation and material cost ranges between $5,569 and $16,149. But in the long run, metal roofs are profitable as they are less likely to need repair. Additionally, the metal used in roof-making can be recycled and used for future purposes.

Which Is Best For Your Home? 

As you know, considering the roofing material for your home is a crucial decision you have to make. Because both types of roofing material have advantages and disadvantages, choosing which is best for you can be intimidating. No worries, we are here to address the following factors that will affect how you make your choice.

Your Roofing Design

Your roof design is an important factor to consider when making a decision. The material you choose will depend on your roof’s pitch, the complexity of the design, and more. If you want to be sure about the proper material for your roof design, you can call a professional for an inspection.

Your Environment

The environment is one of the most crucial aspects to consider. If you live in areas where high winds are common, metal roofs may be the best fit for your home. Or, if you live in an area where the weather is not your primary concern, asphalt shingles may work for you.

Your Budget

Your budget will be a primary guide for which roofing material you choose. Metal roofs are the best option for homeowners who don’t want to shell out more money down the road for costly repairs or replacements.

Easily Install Metal Or Shingle Roofs In South Jersey

Installing a roof, regardless of the material, is a time-consuming process. Once you decide on a material, you want to ensure that it’s installed properly and will efficiently protect your home and family. If you’re still unsure about which roofing material is right for you, or are looking for a professional to install or replace your existing roof, look no further than the team at Champion Exteriors.

Here at Champion Exteriors, we are the roofing experts of South Jersey, and can offer a free inspection when you call! We have been serving in South Jersey for 85 years, and want to help you! Our team of experts provides roofing services for both residential and commercial properties, as well as service on siding and gutters. Contact us today at, (609) 845-3576 to learn more about our roofing services, and receive a free inspection!

Testimonials

We Love To Hear From You

Skip to content