Fascia Board Repair vs. Replacement: Which Option Is Best for Your Roof?

Fascia Board Repair vs. Replacement: Which Option Is Best for Your Roof?

The fascia, for many people, sounds like a new term when they start their roofing project. Though it is one of the most critical components of a roofing system that helps prevent numerous types of damage, it is often not considered. However, in this post, we’ll provide an extensive explanation along with whether you should choose fascia board repair, or replacement. 

What Is a Fascia Board? 

Before understanding what a fascia board is, we need to understand why having one is important. So, let’s start with the roof overhang, where the fascia board is installed. 

A roof overhang is a part of the roof that extends past the outer walls of the home. It is typically extended to keep water flowing off the roof and away from the siding. In general, and usually in every home, the overhang isn’t left open to the elements. As the roof decking is typically made of wood, leaving the eaves open can allow moisture to enter the attic and cause the shingles to deteriorate or fall off. To prevent this, a fascia board is installed along the roofline, providing a finished appearance to the edge of the roof, supporting the bottom row of tiles or shingles, and helping to keep the attic free from moisture.

A roof fascia board is a long, straight board that is typically mounted along the edge of the roof and perpendicular to the roof’s soffit. It is commonly made from wood but can also be made from PVC or other materials.

What Is Fascia Trim? 

Fascia trim deserves a mention in this post as well, as one of the reasons for fascia damage can be fascia trim failure. It is a sheet or decorative molding that is installed along the top of the fascia board to enhance its appearance and prevent water damage. Fascia trim is made of durable materials, such as aluminum, vinyl, or steel, to protect the fascia from rotting, cracking, and splitting. By covering the exposed surface of the fascia board, fascia trim adds an extra layer of protection against the elements, which can help to extend the life of the fascia board and reduce the need for maintenance and repairs.”

Signs of Fascia Board Damage

Fascia boards frequently come in contact with moisture, which can lead to damage. If you see any of the following signs, it is time to repair or replace them. 

Sagging Gutters

Since one of the main jobs of a fascia board is to hold up the gutter system on your home, if your fascia board becomes damaged, your gutter system is likely to become damaged as well. In addition, if there are any holes in your gutters water may leak through these holes, eventually leading to fascia board damage due to moisture. 

If you want to know more about gutters, read our extensive homeowner’s guide to the gutter system

Rotting Wood

Typically made of wood, fascia boards can rot and decay over time due to exposure to moisture from rainwater running off the roof and flowing through gutters. This water can cause damage to the fascia board and threaten its durability. Furthermore, if moisture seeps into the wood fascia board, it can lead to rot and decay, which can shorten the board’s lifespan.

Peeling Paint and Discoloration

Peeling paint on a fascia board indicates its age or level of exposure to the elements. Over time, paint on a fascia board can become brittle and start to crack or peel, particularly if the board has not been properly maintained, or if the paint was not correctly applied. 

Additionally, the water penetrating the fascia board causes the wood fibers to break down and decompose, leading it to rot. As the wood fibers break down, the surface of the board may become discolored or develop a fungal growth that can cause the paint to peel or blister. 

Cracking or Splitting

When fascia boards become cracked, or the wood splits into parts, they can no longer hold up the gutters. Cracking or splitting of fascia results in its deterioration, which can’t be resolved without repair or replacement. Therefore, if you notice any alarming signs of damage in roof fascia boards, you must promptly call professionals for assistance. By leaving them to worsen you may end up paying more for fascia board repair or replacement later on. 

Fascia Board

Choosing Between Repair and Replacement

Choosing between repair and replacement of your fascia board can be daunting. Read the following factors to help determine which one you should go with. 

1. The Severity of Damage

The severity of the damage is one important consideration. If the damage is minor, such as a small crack or gap, it may be possible to repair the fascia board rather than replace it. However, if the damage is more extensive, such as rot or structural damage, it may be necessary to replace the fascia board entirely.

2. Age of the Fascia Board

The age of the fascia board is another important consideration when choosing whether to repair or replace it. If the board is relatively new or in a repairable condition, then there is no benefit in replacing it. However, if the roof fascia board is old or has rotted through, replacing it completely is important. 

3. Roofing Material

When choosing between repair and replacement of the fascia board, it is important to consider the roofing material you have installed. If your roof has heavy materials, such as tile or slate, you’ll want to ensure that the fascia board is replaced or repaired with material that can adequately support the weight of the roof.

4. Budget

Finally, budget is another important factor to consider when deciding whether to repair or replace the fascia board. If the cost of repairing the board is significantly lower than the cost of replacement, it may make sense to opt for repairs. However, if the damage is extensive, or the board is old and likely to require additional repairs in the future, it may be more cost-effective to invest in a replacement.

Repairing a Damaged Fascia Board

Depending on the size of the damage and the advice of your local roofer, you may be able to repair your damaged fascia board yourself.

  1. Steps To Repair a Damaged Fascia Board:
  • Identify the damaged area and remove any damaged or rotten sections of the board.
  • Replace the damaged section with a new piece of wood or other material that matches the existing fascia board.
  • Secure the new piece of board in place with screws or nails.
  • Sand and paint the new section to match the existing fascia board.

B. Benefits of Repair Over Replacement:

Here are some pros of repairing fascia boards over replacement. 

1. Cost-effective: Repairing a fascia board is often less expensive than replacing it.

2. Maintains the original look: Repairing a fascia board can help maintain the original look and character of the building.

3. Faster process: Repairing a fascia board is typically a faster process than replacing it.

C. Cost Considerations

The cost of repairing a fascia board will depend on the extent of the damage, the material of the board, and the cost of labor. If the damage is minor and limited in scope, repairing the fascia board may be a more cost-effective solution than replacing it. 

Replacing a Damaged Fascia Board

Here are some steps you need to take for fascia board replacement. 

A. Steps To Replace a Damaged Fascia Board:

  • Remove the damaged fascia board, being careful not to damage any underlying roofing material or trim.
  • Inspect the surrounding area for any signs of water damage or rot and address those issues before installing the new fascia board.
  • Install the new fascia board, securing it with screws or nails.
  • Sand and paint the new board to match the existing fascia.

B. Benefits of Replacement Over Repair:

1. Longer-lasting solution: Replacing a fascia board can provide a longer-lasting solution than repairs.

2. Can upgrade material: Replacing a fascia board can provide an opportunity to upgrade to a more durable or low-maintenance material.

3. Better structural support: Replacing a fascia board can ensure that the building has adequate structural support.

C. Cost Considerations

The fascia board replacement cost will depend on the size of the board, the material chosen, and the cost of labor. While replacing a fascia board can be more expensive than repairing it, it may be a better long-term solution if the damage is severe or extensive. 

Hiring a Professional

When it comes to fascia board replacement or repair, it is important to hire a qualified professional to ensure that the work is done properly and safely. A qualified professional will have the necessary knowledge, skills, and tools to complete the job efficiently and effectively.

Working with a professional also ensures that the work is done in compliance with local building codes. 

Best Fascia Board Repair and Replacement Services in Hainesport

Now that you know how a damaged fascia board can hurt your home’s appearance while reducing the lifespan of your roof, it is important to hire a trusted and reliable roofer or contractor who is an expert at his job. 

We are a team of experienced professionals at Champion Exteriors. More importantly, we are proficient at handling all exterior services, including repairing and replacing fascia boards, gutters, and siding.   

Call us today at (609)-845-3576 for a free consultation. We are always here to assist you!